P= Pride of Orkney, 12 y/o blended malt
S= Scapa, 1993 (bottled 2008) single malt
H= Highland Park, 8 y/o single malt
Bottler: Gordon & McPhail, Elgin, Moray, Scotland, UK.
P= Highland Park, Scapa.
S= Scapa, Kirkwall, Orkney, Scotland, UK (Pernod-Ricard)
H= Highland Park, Kirkwall, Orkney, Scotland, UK (Edrington)
P: 12 y/o
S: 15 y/o
H: 8 y/o
Price: I forget.
P: Medium caramel.
S: Lighter. Straw.
H: Virtually the same as P.
P: Alcohol, oak, malt, a little peat.
S: Mild.Oak, seabreeze.
H: Toasted almonds, oak, peach.
P: Medium bodied and creamy. Caramel, bourbon.
S: Mild. Not much happening but a little burn.
H: Mild. Butterscotch, peat, lemon meringue.
P: Mild and slightly sweet. Caramel, buttercream.
S: A little fruity. Fades quickly.
H: Slightly chewy but mild. Peat ash, Atlantic ocean.
Parting words: These whiskies come from the two most northerly distilleries in Scotland, Highland Park and the other one in Orkney, Scapa. Highland Park is almost universally beloved for its perfectly balanced and flavorful 12 & 18 y/o bottlings. Scapa is not nearly as well known or highly regarded as HP, but the 16 y/o producer bottling does have its fans. Scapa is unpeated, unusual for a an Island malt, but they did release a peated expression last year.
Pride of Orkney (of G & M’s now defunct “Pride of” series) is a blended malt containing whisky from both of these distilleries. It’s the best of the three. While it’s not earth shattering, it is well balanced with good flavor considering its proof and the fact that it’s a blended malt containing some pretty mild whisky. I suspect it contains caramel coloring. The Highland Park 8 y/o is fine for what it is, a young malt from a good distillery. Higher ABV would do it a lot of favors, but it’s pleasant enough as it is.
Scapa 1993 is one of the dullest single malts I’ve ever had. It doesn’t do anything to distinguish itself, tasting like a generic second-tier single malt. It’s like eating a sleeve of water crackers. It will do if there’s nothing else in the house but you’re left feeling like you just wasted time and calories for nothing.
These three expressions are close to impossible to find on their own now, but I bought this set of minis at a large liquor store just a couple years ago so there are probably more of these sets floating around out there. There is/was also an Islay tripak set. Probably more interesting than this. If you’re curious about the whiskies of Orkney, you might find the Orkney tripak fun but I can only mildly recommend this set.
One thought on “Triple Head to Head: G & M Orkney Tripak”
I’ve tried Scapa 16 and also found it incredibly generic. Not a distillery I seek out after hearing enough reviews in that vein.
The HP 8 is just fine for the money, but I’d rather spend a few extra dollars to get the OB HP 12. But I think the Macphail’s Collection 8 Year bottles are mostly trying to pull in blend drinkers looking to upgrade, so I’m not too surprised that they didn’t use the highest quality casks.