Maker: Heaven Hill, Louisville, Kentucky, USA
Style: Wheated Bourbon
Age: 12 y/o
Proof: 90 (45% ABV)
Appearance: Dark auburn with quick legs.
Nose: Burn, sweet taffy, caramel, pecans. With a splash of water, cola notes pop out.
On the palate: Medium bodied. Cherry pie, pecan pie, and mincemeat pie (in that order). The nutty notes get stronger and stronger as it sits in the glass, until they begin to taste more grapey, like in a brandy. Water doesn’t change any of this too much, except to bring the nutty notes forward more quickly.
Finish: surprisingly dry. Burn, then some bitter walnut flavors and a reserved sweetness.
Parting words: Very Special Old Fitzgerald (VSOF) doesn’t get much respect in bourbon circles these days. It never really has. It was originally a part of the Bourbon Heritage Collection in which it played second fiddle to the revered wheater Weller Centennial. Centennial was 10 y/o and 100 proof, whereas VSOF was and is 12 y/o and 90 proof. I’ve had VSOF from that era and they are mild to the point of being dull. VSOF wasn’t helped by the fact that it was preceded by Very Old Fitzgerald and Very Very Old Fitzgerald which are regarded by wheater enthusiasts as two of the greatest bourbons ever made. Bottles of VOF and VVOF routinely go for hundreds of dollars on Ebay.
Compared to its current rival from the Buffalo Trace, Weller 12 y/o (also 90 proof), it seems a bit sluggish and muddled. Weller 12 has a bright acidic note that cuts through the rich brandy flavors and brings the fruit to the fore. If VSOF is mincemeat pie, Weller 12 is apple pie. Both are good, but unfortunately for the folks at Heaven Hill, Weller 12 is usually at least $5 cheaper than VSOF. Nevertheless, if the price is right (≤$35) VSOF is recommended.
2 thoughts on “Very Special Old Fitzgerald”
i have a old gift set of fitzgerald comes in what looks like a book w 2 shot glasses 1 pint seals not broken distilled in1955 anyone know how much this is worth? melissa
Sorry, I don’t do free appriaisals. I would recommend you contact an auction house in a state where liquor auctions are legal.